Skip to content
GK LibraryA home for curious minds
English

Library Material Selection Criteria and Priorities - Demand Theory and Value Theory

In this article, we aim to present information on the criteria and priorities for selecting library materials. Libraries select and purchase a variety of book and non-book materials for purposes such as collecting and preserving materials and providing user services, and because this involves a substantial budget, they must decide what to prioritize.

 

The criteria for selecting materials include demand theory and value theory, each with its own characteristics and limitations, which have led scholars to continually discuss them as opposing approaches.

 

This article aims to examine the concepts and limitations of demand theory and value theory and to provide information that can help readers consider which materials should take priority in different types of libraries.

 

Value Theory

Give priority to valuable materials in selection Give priority to valuable materials in selection

Value theory is a theory in which a library establishes criteria for assessing the value of materials before purchasing them and uses these criteria as the basis for selecting materials. In other words, the library selects and provides materials that users ought to read.

 

This theory, which emphasizes the value of materials, encompasses not only the value of documentary resources but also the value sought by users, ultimately enhancing the value of the library through its materials.

 

It is mainly adopted as a basis for selecting materials by university libraries, which emphasize documentary resources and library functions.

​

Limitations of Value Theory
  • The criteria for judging books are ambiguous, leaving room for subjectivity.
  • Questions may arise about the justification for selecting materials that go unused.
  • Librarians are not knowledgeable enough to select books on every subject.
  • Dissatisfaction increases if the selected books fall below the user group's level.

 

Demand Theory

Give priority to materials that users want in selection Give priority to materials that users want in selection

Demand theory is a theory that stands in opposition to value theory and a method of selecting materials by giving priority to those requested by library users. Even when users do not explicitly express their needs, any conscious or unconscious needs discerned in their behavior are regarded as user demands.

 

Various techniques are also used to identify user demands directly. These include face-to-face surveys of users, analysis of usage records, and community surveys.

 

However, these methods cannot measure user demands perfectly, and they have limitations because there is still room for the investigator's subjective influence.

 

Demand theory, as described above, is more suitable for public libraries that serve a large and diverse local population than for university libraries that handle valuable materials such as academic resources. This is also because public libraries are funded by taxes and therefore have an obligation to incorporate user demands into their operations.

 

Limitations of Demand Theory
  • If materials are selected solely in response to demand, there is no longer any value in having librarians.
  • It is difficult to respond when demands vary widely.
  • If purchases focus on temporary demand (such as bestsellers), the quality of the collection declines.
  • Demand theory is a democratic approach to selection, but it overlooks the fact that readers' tastes are shaped by 'economies of scale'.

​* Economies of scale: earning a profit when output doubles while production costs increase to less than twice their original level (i.e., increased profits)

 

Priorities for Material Selection by Library Type

Considerations for Material Selection by Library Type Considerations for Material Selection by Library Type

As with the value theory and demand theory described above, the criteria for prioritizing materials vary by library type according to each library's characteristics. Various factors come into play together, including the library's purpose, users' characteristics and requirements, and the size of its budget.

 

Libraries may favor either value theory or demand theory as their basis for selecting materials, or they may strike an appropriate balance between the two theories and use them to complement each other in library operations.

 

To make a judgment on this matter, it is necessary to understand the characteristics of each library type; please refer to the table above, where these are summarized.

 

 

 

We have now examined value theory and demand theory, which should be understood when selecting materials in libraries, and the characteristics of different library types relevant to applying these theories.

 

There is no definitive right answer when it comes to the criteria for selecting materials. Based on a comprehensive assessment of what should be given greater importance and the library's current situation and purpose, one approach may be given more weight, or both may be applied in an appropriate balance.

 

We hope you will consider which theory interests you more and make a wise choice by taking into account the characteristics and limitations of each.

Keep this article as a PDF

Buy the selected-language edition of the article you are reading.

US$1.00
Selected language: English

US$1.00 · one article · one language

Choose how to buy

Buy as a member
  • Log in on any device to download again
  • Kept in your purchase history
Buy without an account
  • Pay right away with no sign-up
  • Download again in this browser
  • On other devices, use the personal link shown after purchase
  • If you later log in as a member in this browser, your purchases move to your account
  • If you lose the link and clear this browser’s cookies, downloading again may not be possible

Checking your purchases…

Seller information

Business name
아카이지
Representative
안호원
Business registration No.
530-02-04118
Mail-order sales report No.
2026-경기군포-0626
Reporting authority
경기도 군포시
Business address
경기도 군포시 산본천로 119-9, 1109동 405호 (산본동, 주공아파트)
Hosting provider
카페24(주)
Contact email
sgjjojo@gmail.com
Contact number
010-4194-0821

Verify seller information (Korea FTC)